Groped by Patients

Admin

by Elizabeth E. Hogue, Esq. | Jun 27, 2025 | Admin, Caregiver Safety, Clinical

by Elizabeth E. Hogue, Esq.

Groped by Patients

Just a Slap on the Wrist

Many aides in a variety of healthcare settings have been the victims of unwanted touching or groping. What should they do? In Dorothy Bills v. WVNH Emp, LLC, and Lanette Kuhnash [No. 2:22-cv-00093 (S.D.W. Va., 2022)], the Court concluded that slapping the hands of groping patients is inappropriate conduct.

In this case, a Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA), Dorothy Bills, was responsible for the care of a patient who had limited mental capacity. He could not control his actions or understand their effect. He was sexually aggressive, and staff members had already been instructed to care for him in pairs.

Dorothy Strikes Back

Dorothy Bills was in the patient’s room alone while another nurse was on her break. She moved close to the patient’s bed to speak to him because he was hard of hearing. The CNA leaned closer to the patient to provide water and to help him stay in bed as he tried to sit up. As she did so, the patient reached out and touched Ms. Bills’ breast and vaginal area. He touched her inappropriately on multiple occasions when she cared for him, so she smacked his hands in response and told him that it wasn’t nice to touch her.

A coworker told Ms. Bills that slapping the patient’s hands was abuse and she must report the incident.

Agency Policy

The provider, WVNH, had a policy that prohibited physical abuse, including any form of corporal punishment defined as physical punishment used as a means to correct or control the patient’s behavior. The policy specifically prohibited slapping patients’ hands.

Rapid Escalation

The CNA filed an incident report that said she smacked the Patient’s hands three times. She said she didn’t slap him hard enough to hurt him, but just as one would a child who was misbehaving. As a result, a report was made to adult protective services and Ms. Bills was suspended. Adult protective services dropped the allegation of neglect. The CNA’s employment was terminated and her license later expired.

Groped by Patients, and the Court

Ms. Bills filed suit several years later on the basis that her termination was wrongful because it was in retaliation for resisting sexual harassment. She described slapping the patient’s hands and scolding him to “reprimand” him “like you would a child misbehaving” in both the incident report she filed and during her deposition. Consequently, the Court said that the only issue is whether employers are prohibited from firing employees who physically punish a patient in response to sexual harassment.

The Court concluded that smacking patients’ hands and scolding them are inappropriate activities. Physically punishing patients, said the Court, is not a reasonable means of opposing sexual harassment by them. Filing complaints and asking for protective measures is appropriate. The CNA appealed the Court’s decision to the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit. On April 29, 2024, the appeals court issued a decision upholding the lower Court’s opinion.

Prevention as a Cure for Being Groped by Patients

Here are some practical actions that may help prevent sexual harassment of staff members by patients:

Providers should require staff members to document and report every instance of sexual harassment by patients.
Staff members who violate the policy should be disciplined.
Patients should be evaluated by appropriate clinical staff to determine whether medication may be helpful to address inappropriate touching.
Staff members should receive education and training on a regular basis about the causes of inappropriate touching and how to address it.

Final Thoughts

The bottom line is that sexual harassment is not a part of the job description of staff members and providers must take appropriate steps to protect them.

# # #

Elizabeth Hogue is an attorney in private practice with extensive experience in health care. She represents clients across the U.S., including professional associations, managed care providers, hospitals, long-term care facilities, home health agencies, durable medical equipment companies, and hospices.

No portion of this material may be reproduced in any form without the advance written permission of the author.

©2025 by The Rowan Report, Peoria, AZ. All rights reserved. This article originally appeared in The Rowan Report. One copy may be printed for personal use: further reproduction by permission only. editor@therowanreport.com

Workplace Violence in Home Health

Caregiver Safety

by Kristin Rowan | Jun 20, 2025 | Caregiver Safety, Caring for the Caregiver, Clinical, Home Health, Hospice

by Kristin Rowan, Editor

Workplace Violence and Policy Impact

Study of home health workers

A group of researchers from the University of Cincinnati, Ohio published a recent study¹ on the frequency and reporting procedures of workplace violence (WPV) in home healthcare. The study specifically addressed WPV in home healthcare, stating limited understanding of WPV in the home care setting. Most existing studies on WPV were hospital-based.

Frequency of Workplace Violence

Of the home health care workers (HHCW) surveyed, almost 37% responded that they experience both verbal and emotional violence in the workplace daily. More than 80% reported experiencing verbal aggression at some point. Physical violence is less prominent. 20% of respondants said they experience physical violence monthly. However, 56.6% said they have experienced physical violence at some point in their current agency. 76.6% of the time, the perpetrators of the violence are the patients of the HHCW.

Fig. 1 Frequency of occurrence of physical, verbal, emotional, and sexual abuse as a function of time: daily, weekly, monthly, <yearly, yearly, and never.

Reporting Workplace Violence

All of the study participants indicated they had knowledge of workplace violence reporting procedures in their agencies, but 26.7% were unsure if the policies are contained in the employee handbook. 46.7% were uncertain as to whether the agency offered WPV or de-escalation training and 66% said prevention and de-escalation training was not mandatory. Unfortunately, 40% said their management did not encourage reporting and 33% said they were not comfortable approaching management about WPV. Despite the frequency of WPV among the respondents, none of the participants reported these incidents to management.

Thoughts

According to this, and other research studies on workplace violence in home healthcare, the problem is prevalent and persistent. Most HHCWs have experienced some sort of aggression, violence, or abuse in the course of performing their jobs. Of those who have, most do not report the incidents to management. Most HHCWs have not been trained in prevention or de-escalation. Even with training, HHCWs need a way to get immediate help. Unfortunately, most do not have an emergency alert system on their person during home visits.

Solution

Care at Home agencies, including non-medical supportive care, home health, hospice, and any other lone workers who are visiting patients in their homes, need safety policies and procedures. Agencies must include the same in the employee handbook, explain during orientation, and make available to HHCWs digitally.

Policies and procedures should include:

A safety committee comprised of management, back office staff, and field workers
A clearly written policy regarding physical, emotional, verbal, and sexual abuse
- Against a patient or their family/friends by a HHCW
- Against a HHCW by a patient or their family/friends
- Against a HHCW by a colleague or manager
- Against a HHCW by the environment in which they work (i.e. aggressive pets, weapons, cigarette smoking indoors, etc.)
A digital reporting system that employees can use without having to approach management individually
A clearly written policy on the management response to violence reporting
A clearly written policy forbidding any retaliation or discrimination against a reporting employee
Required research about new patients including
- Background/History of violence and/or mental instability
- Neighborhood safety rating
- Family members likely to be in the home and their history of violence and/or mental instability

Additional Tools for HHCWs

Workplace violence against HHCWs is not “if,” but “when.” It is the responsibility of the agencies to lower the risk, lower the percentage of “whens,” and encourage reporting. If you’re not sure how to begin, hire a consultant to help you build your safety committee and write your policies. It doesn’t matter how you start implementing safety protocols, as long as you follow through and protect your employees.

# # #

Kristin Rowan has been working at The Rowan Report since 2008. She is the owner and Editor-in-chief of The Rowan Report, the industry’s most trusted source for care at home news, and speaker on Artificial Intelligence and Lone Worker Safety and state and national conferences.

She also runs Girard Marketing Group, a multi-faceted boutique marketing firm specializing in content creation, social media management, and event marketing. Connect with Kristin directly kristin@girardmarketinggroup.com or www.girardmarketinggroup.com

1. Obariase, E.; Bellacov, R.; Gillespie, G.; Davis, K. (2025). Assessing Workplace Violence and Policy Impact: A Cross-sectional Study of Home Healthcare Workers. Home Healthcare Now, 43(3), 150-156. doi: 10.1097/NHH.0000000000001345

More Violence in Care at Home

Admin

by Elizabeth E. Hogue, Esq. | Mar 21, 2025 | Admin, Caregiver Safety, Caring for the Caregiver, Clinical

by Elizabeth E. Hogue, Esq.

Violence Against Home Care Providers Continues

Violence in Care at Home Continues…

Sadly, but not surprisingly, the violence against field staff caring for patients in their homes continues. Here’s a recent example:

On February 28, 2025, a hospice nurse in Texas was accosted inside a patient’s home while she was attempting to provide care. The man who accosted her inside the home followed her outside with a rifle and fired at her as she fled. The nurse was uninjured, but her car was struck by at least one bullet.

Then, still armed, the man went back inside the patient’s home where he stayed close to the patient while pointing his rifle at deputies. Law enforcement officers were able to communicate with him and de-escalate the tense situation. The man was booked into the county jail on a charge of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and bond was set at $250,000.

By the Numbers

According to a recent analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics data, healthcare is one of the most dangerous places to work. Homecare field staff members who provide services on behalf of private duty agencies, hospices, Medicare-certified home health agencies, and home medical equipment (HME) companies may be especially vulnerable. Contributing to their vulnerability is the fact that they work alone on territory that may be unfamiliar and over which they have little control. Staff members certainly need as much protection as possible.

Violence Policies Needed

First, regardless of practice setting, management should develop a written policy of zero tolerance for all incidents of violence, regardless of source. This policy should include animals. The policy must require employees and contractors to report and document all incidents of threatened or actual violence, no matter how minor.

Beyond Reporting

Emphasis should be placed on both reporting and documenting. Employees must provide as much detail as possible. The policy should also include zero tolerance for visible weapons. Caregivers must be required to report the presence of visible weapons.

UCHealth SAFE Program

Below are some additional important actions for healthcare organizations to take that are based on the UCHealth SAFE Program:

Encourage staff members to STOP if they feel unsafe for any reason.
If danger is not imminent, workers should pause to generally ASSESS their environments. Staff members should think about what happened and observe what is currently happening. Is there, for example, mounting frustration or anger?
Staff should then FAMILIARIZE themselves with the area. Who is the patient? Where is the patient? Are there any factors that might escalate behaviors? Staff members should also consider putting themselves in positions where they have a route to escape, if necessary.
ENLIST help. Getting help may, for example, include pushing panic buttons on mobile devices.

In Their Own Words

Here is what Chris Powell, Chief of Security at UCHealth, said in Becker’s Hospital Review on June 4, 2024:

“You can’t just talk about the shrimp and give you a good picture. We have to talk about the roux and the rice and everything else that goes into this for a good picture to be painted so people have an understanding. We want to solve this with an electronic learning or a 15-minute huddle, but we can’t. This is continuous and a persistent pursuit toward educating, communicating, recognizing, responding to, reporting and recovering from workplace violence.”

Chris Powell

Chief of Security, UCHealth

Final Thoughts

Every caregiver matters. The healthcare industry has lost caregivers to violence on the job in the past. Let’s do all that we can to avoid similar events in the future.

# # #

No portion of this material may be reproduced in any form without the advance written permission of the author.

Safeguarding Caregivers from Violence

Admin

by Kristin Rowan | Feb 27, 2025 | Admin, Caregiver Safety, Caring for the Caregiver, Clinical

by Kristin Rowan, Editor

We’ve published and talked a lot about caregiver safety, lone worker safety, and keeping your caregivers safe. Until the risk of violence to care at home workers is 0%, we will continue to provide this information and urge you to implement plans to lower the risk.

It’s nice to see that we’re not the only ones. Much of the following information comes from Lockton Affinity Home Care, along with reports from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Workplace Violence in Care at Home

Workplace violence is at a much higher risk among home care workers than other professions. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics says that home health aides and home nursing assistance are five to seven times more likely to experience workplace violance than the average U.S. worker. Workplace violence can include verbal, non-verbal and written harrassment, bullying, sexual harassment, and physical attacks, up to and including death. A study from the CDC is discouraging:

Violence Stats from Centers for Disease Control & Prevention

18% to 65% of workers experiencing verbal abuse from patients
As many as 41% workers have reported sexual harassment
Between 2.5% and 44% of workers have reported being physically assaulted

Negative Consequences to Your Agency

According to Lockton, caregivers are impacted by violence in more ways than one. In addition to the physical and mental harm done by the violence itself, caregivers suffer from lower job satisfaction and higher burnout rates. They also may provide lower quality of care. Some start abusing drugs and alcohol. All of these lead to higher employee turnover and greater cost to the agency to hire and train new staff. Additionally, the poor quality of an abused worker can damage an agencies efficiency as well as their reputation.

Collect information and monitor conditions in the environment

Training, Policies, and Reporting

Lockton offers some specific recommendations to reduce the likelihood of your caregivers experiencing workplace violence.

Home care businesses should implement a monitoring and reporting process to demonstrate their commitment to recognizing and mitigating the risks associated with workplace violence.

By proactively managing workplace violence risks, your business can enable staff protection and support, align with regulatory compliance, emphasize a culture of safety, inform data-driven decision-making and contribute to the overall well-being of both employees and clients.

Implementation recommendations include:

A zero-tolerance policy towards workplace violence.
Policies and rules on the safety of lone caregivers in the field, such as regular cell phone contact or check-ins, and conducting home visits in pairs and/or with security escorts.
Rules and strategies related to visits in homes where violence has occurred in the past.

Require staff to participate in ongoing education and training

Many incidents of workplace violence go unreported in the industry. Caregivers may perceive incidents as minor or as part of the job, leading to a lack of action and normalization of such behavior.

Training employees on the types of physical and nonphysical acts and threats of workplace violence can increase awareness and reduce normalization. Additional education and training can focus on how to:

Assess the work environment and surroundings for safety, including the presence of drugs of abuse, drug paraphernalia, weapons, and aggressive pets.
Recognize signs of imminent violence, including verbal abuse and aggressive body language and/or posturing.
Employ verbal de-escalation techniques.
Utilize escape and egress techniques.

Create and maintain a culture of safety and quality throughout the organization

Identify an individual to be responsible for your organization’s workplace violence prevention program. They can implement policies and a standardized process to report and follow up on events or near-misses. Data collection and simple, accessible reporting structures show commitment to providing a safe and secure work environment. Regularly reporting incidents and trends to governance promotes transparency and further establishes accountability for the program.

Post-incident support services can also have great value for home healthcare workers’ well-being. These services may include peer support, formal debriefing, trauma-crisis counseling and employee assistance programs.

# # #

Kristin Rowan has been working at The Rowan Report since 2008. She is the owner and Editor-in-chief of The Rowan Report, the industry’s most trusted source for care at home news .She also has a master’s degree in business administration and marketing and runs Girard Marketing Group, a multi-faceted boutique marketing firm specializing in content creation, social media management, and event marketing. Connect with Kristin directly kristin@girardmarketinggroup.com or www.girardmarketinggroup.com