Can This New Software Eliminate Fraud and Billing Errors?
Adminby Tim Rowan, Editor Emeritus
Software Eliminates Fraud and Errors
Like so many Home Care providers, Aspen Home Care in Kansas City, Missouri was drowning in paper. Two hundred caregivers turned in weekly timesheets every Friday. A large office staff had to go through them, looking for errors, omissions, and unauthorized visits and shifts. Submitting erroneous claims, of course, leads to payment denials, even fines. When an agency submits too many bad claims every week over a long period, a surveyor will soon be knocking at their door.
The Hurdles
On a good week, Aspen completed all necessary payroll and billing tasks and had bills ready to submit by end of business on the following Thursday. Slowing down the process were the usual errors — forgotten check-outs, more hours worked than authorized, and late timesheet submission. Caregivers grew weary of the weekly phone calls asking for clarification, even when the error was their fault. Aspen did have a basic billing system, but paper timesheets fed it too. Electronic Visit Verification was possible, but only via a patient’s landline, using punched-in identification codes.
Then... the call came
“After years of software design, we have completed our replacement for your billing and EVV system. We would like you to switch from the basic system we sold you a few years ago and beta test our better one.”
– Henry (Hank) Schwab, Owner, Compliance Plus
Beta testing is a risky venture, but both owner Ahmed Jara and Office Manager Mohammed Mohammed* trusted Hank and agreed to give it a try. After all, the agency was drowning in paper, they reminded each other.
Dramatic Process Improvements
We took part in a demo of the Compliance Plus system before speaking with Mohammed and hearing Aspen’s experience. We saw a comprehensive, user-friendly system, with a color-coded user interface, that includes scheduling, EVV, and billing for Medicaid, Managed Care, and all other payers an agency contracts with.
Time Tracking
Caregivers clock in and out with an app that is GPS-enabled down to exact longitude and latitude coordinates. Should a patient live in an internet dead zone, caregivers can use their landline. If there is no landline, Aspen will install a “smart fob” in the home. Aspen does not require specific visit start times, but once a check-in is recorded, the app knows the patient’s authorized hours and automatically alerts the caregiver when it is time to clock out.
Verification
Mistakes do happen, of course, but fixing them is not difficult. When the Compliance Plus back end sees a 14-hour visit, it assumes the caregiver forgot to check out. The visit flashes red on the screen, indicating it is not ready to bill, and displays the difference between authorized and recorded hours. The office employee managing exceptions simply calls the caregiver for verification and then manually edits the end time, and compliance is maintained.
Caregiver Feedback
Mohammed told us his caregiving staff is thrilled with the app, though he did say the transition was hard at first. “They learn to use it in about 30 minutes,” he said. “Check-in and check-in take a few seconds and now they are happy to be done with paper forever, not to mention no longer having to deliver paper timesheets to the office.” He added that fake check-ins from the car on the way to a patient’s home have been completely eliminated.
Most importantly, the three-person office staff now completes payroll and billing for 200 caregivers by midday on Tuesday instead of late on Thursday.
The "Plus" of Compliance Plus
Certainly, procedural efficiencies are important, and many scheduling and EVV systems force caregivers to check in and check out in the presence of the patient and alert office staff when a caregiver arrives late or is a no-show. What we saw during our demo, however, we have not seen elsewhere. Compliance Plus automates the tedious task of rooting out EVV, billing, and payroll errors so efficiently, payment denials, aggregator rejections, and incorrect paychecks are virtually eliminated.
Denials are Rare
Mohammed confirmed what we saw in the demo. The file that includes hours, authorizations, patient demographics, and pre-arranged pay rates is prepared and perfected in advance. Then, the system uploads the same corrected file to the aggregator and to state and other payers. “If we need to fix hours or a bill, we do it before uploading to all entities,” he said. “We rarely get rejections from the aggregator or denials from payers.”
Aggregated Data
One of the requirements of payers and EVV aggregators is that all patient and caregiver names and other information must be in their respective databases in advance. Compliance Plus finds missing data and removes a bill from the file before it is uploaded, notifying the user with a red flag. Mohammed added, “We have to make sure all patient data is in system, but that is easy to do.”
Implementation and Training
In every home care agency, there is always a measure of trepidation among the staff when switching from familiar paper to automation. Aspen Home Care was no different when owner Ahmed Jara announced that he had accepted Hank’s invitation to join a beta test. Mohammed told us that his staff’s time from implementation to software expertise took a little less than three months. Compliance Plus customer relationship manager Sara Moore conducted online training of key office staff, a service that is included in Aspen’s monthly fee. Mohammed and a couple others trained the rest of the staff on the full system and then caregivers on the use of the app.
“After a short while, the new system became our normal workflow,” Mohammed commented. “The only speed bump is when they upload new features. We need to spend a little time learning them, but ultimately, the new features improve our workflow. Our caregivers pick up the app in about 30 minutes, including new hires.”
Favorite Features
He added that his 200 caregivers like checking in and out on the app better than the legacy ANI system, which used the patient’s landline for automatic number identification. “English is a second language for some of our caregivers, and they sometimes had trouble with the ANI prompts spoken by the computerized voice,” he explained. “GPS verification is the best feature. If a caregiver checks in from too far away, we see their distance from the patient’s home on a map, and we gently ‘re-educated’ them and it does not happen again. In the past, they would sometimes get away with asking a family member to check in for them from the patient’s landline. Those days are gone.”
He also told us that Aspen does not insist on specific start times. What matters is that visit length matches authorized hours over a billing period. This is especially helpful for waiver and HCBS plans when the caregiver lives in the home. In those arrangements, checking in or out used to be easily forgotten. “I take care of her all day, how do I know when I start and stop?” The Compliance Plus app rings its cell phone loudly to remind visiting and live-in caregivers to check in and then to check out after the authorized number of hours have been reached.
Simplifying Complex Billing
Presently, Aspen exclusively serves Medicaid beneficiaries, though that can mean several managed care payers. With varying reimbursement rates from payers, combined with different caregiver hourly rates, getting a bill to match an authorization used to be a challenge for Office Manager Mohammed and his team.
It's Complicated
In the case of an agency employed family caregiver, there are often days when the family member will spend one hour toileting and feeding, the next hour doing reimbursable homemaking chores, and the third hour running care-related errands. Not only might those tasks be paid at different rates, but they can, and often are, reimbursed by different payers.
Patient Profiles
Mohammed emphasized that the way Compliance Plus handles these situations saves considerable time and reduces payer and aggregator rejections. Like in a Venn diagram, every combination of patient, payer, task type, and caregiver creates a “patient profile.” The user created most profiles in advance, based on known payer rates, etc. Occasionally, a patient’s profile is unique, but a user can easily enter the specifics into the system manually. Once a profile is built, the system calculates all of the billing accurately without additional user supervision.
Task Rates
Company Prospects
Hank Schwab told us that he is confident, after 100 successful beta customers, that Compliance Plus is ready for general release. At $10 to $12 per patient per month, he believes that supplementing word-of-mouth with a modest marketing effort will help him replace paper and strengthen the bottom line for many Medicaid and Personal Care agencies. Hank’s plan is to begin that effort as soon as he identifies an investor or two and hires a marketing director. “I already manage a team of coders and personally pay all the bills,” he laughed. “I’m ready for someone else to take on a few of my jobs.”
https://complianceplus.com/
*No, that is not a typo. We also enjoyed Mohammed Mohammed’s sense of humor. He tells people his parents were too cheap to give him a first name, so they just copied his last name.
# # #
Tim@RowanResources.com
©2025 by The Rowan Report, Peoria, AZ. All rights reserved. This article originally appeared in The Rowan Report. One copy may be printed for personal use: further reproduction by permission only. editor@therowanreport.com
Earl L. “Buddy” Carter is an experienced businessman, health care professional and faithful public servant. For over 32 years Buddy owned Carter’s Pharmacy, Inc. where South Georgians trusted him with their most valuable assets: their health, lives and families. While running his business, he learned how to balance a budget and create jobs. He also saw firsthand the devastating impacts of government overregulation which drives his commitment to ensuring that the federal government creates policies to empower business instead of increasing burdens on America’s job creators.
Congressman Ami Bera, M.D. has represented Sacramento County in the U.S. House of Representatives since 2013. The 6th Congressional District is located just east and north of California’s capitol city, Sacramento, and lies entirely within
